BORTZ PRODUCT DESIGN - INDUSTRIAL DESIGN SYDNEY AUSTRALIA
  • Home
  • About us
  • Services
  • Portfolio
    • Blog
    • Resources
  • Contact

LOOK WHAT'S HAPPENING

Do you see in 3D?

11/23/2018

1 Comment

 
Picture
When developing new products, one of the critical tasks a designer has is getting the client to understand what the proposed concept would really look like.

Shown a static 2D image some people struggle to interpret what it may look like in 3D. This is not surprising as there are many interpretations as to what could be happening in an image. We have all seen “optical illusions” in which we are tricked thinking what is out is in, up is down, and curved is flat. If designers are also so easily tricked, how can they expect people not trained to think in 3D to visualise the new concept? At that how could we expect anyone to interpret what the hidden sides of a 2D image looks like?

In a recent project we worked on this issue was really evident on a number of levels. First off, the graphic design company, whom the marketing department worked closely with, was commissioned to provide the initial visual direction. This company is amazing in producing product graphics, labels and branding, but unfortunately all their work is in 2D. They provided front view “realistic” 2D images that were approved by marketing and send on to me to “make real”.

Our first task was to interpret what had been presented, and after mulling it over for a while, we had to call the graphics company to confirm our interpretation was correct. We then had to bring some reality into the picture, as in creating a shaded 2D dwg you can fool yourself into designing shapes that aren’t possible, or cannot be manufactured.
 
We then modeled up the proposal in 3D CAD and using a 3D file format (in which the object can be rotated and viewed from multiple angles) sent it back to the graphics company to see if their “static” realistic 2D and words had actually conveyed their intent. We were close, but even using their image as an underlay for my 3D, proved to be a bit inaccurate. 

The project continued and we were getting great feedback from the graphics and marketing department that we were on the right track. We had got almost to the sign off stage when it happened. Marketing finally discovered that the files we had been sending could be rotated and viewed from any angle, not just the default “static view” it was saved at! What we interpreted and the graphic guys had intended as flattish panels, marketing had interpreted as generous curves! We were back to the beginning, but now thanks to “3D” were all able to see the same thing!

But seeing on screen and making the mental leap to how big or small the part really is, or what it would feel like in your hand is an even more difficult feat. Leveraging the same CAD data used to produce the 3D files, we were able to commission rapid prototypes that were almost true to life and confirmed that what the team has imagined.

From this project quite a few lessons can be learnt;
  • Don’t rely on an interpretation of a static 2D image to convey the complete message
  • Make sure the whole team understands the tools available to them and how they are used.
  • Use quick hand sketches to map the basic direction you and your team are aiming for.  
  • Get into 3D as quickly as possible. If you are designing packs, this will help establish that you are in the ballpark with your volumes, or pack sizes. If you are designing other products such as electronic housings, it will help establish if you can fit the critical items inside.
  • Do a final confirmation using rapid prototyping.
They say a picture speaks a thousand words, but a 3D files speaks millions
​Graphic courtesy of clipartxtras.com
1 Comment

    Author

    Gary Bortz, Director of Bortz Product Design 

    Archives

    November 2024
    August 2024
    April 2022
    January 2022
    June 2021
    March 2021
    January 2021
    October 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    October 2019
    November 2018
    June 2018
    January 2018
    January 2017
    July 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016

    Categories

    All

 Bortz Product Design - Industrial design consultancy


Address

Sydney,  Australia

Telephone

+61 2 9878 0123

Email

[email protected]
  • Home
  • About us
  • Services
  • Portfolio
    • Blog
    • Resources
  • Contact